A magnifying glass over a model house

Appraisal partners · Private appraisal leads

Private Appraisal Leads: Scoping, Pricing and Winning Work

Private appraisal leads pay off when you scope fast: confirm intended use, users and effective date, quote a fixed fee and turnaround, and send an engagement letter.

Non-lending appraisal work rewards appraisers who sound like they have done this exact assignment a hundred times. The homeowner on the phone is usually stressed: a divorce, a death, a tax bill or a sale. This page gives you a scoping matrix by purpose, a pricing worksheet that ties lead cost to fee, and the questions that turn a lead into a signed engagement.

Key takeaways

  • Each purpose has its own intended users, effective date and report expectations.
  • Retrospective assignments (estate, some divorces) need comparable sales from before the effective date.
  • Lead cost should be a small, predictable share of your fee; work it out per purpose.
  • Speed matters most for tax appeals, where deadlines are short and fixed.

How do you scope a private appraisal assignment?

Identify the client, intended use, intended users, effective date, property interest and any special conditions, then match the report type and fee. These are the same elements USPAP requires you to identify for every assignment.

Scoping matrix by lead purpose
PurposeTypical client and usersEffective dateWatch for
Remove PMIHomeowner; servicer may be a user only if it agrees to accept the reportCurrentMany servicers require their own ordered valuation
DivorceOne or both spouses, their attorneys, sometimes the courtCurrent or date of separationPossible deposition or testimony; neutral tone
Estate or trustExecutor, trustee, estate attorney or CPADate of death (retrospective)Access to a vacant home; condition at date of death
Tax appealHomeowner or tax consultant; assessor and board as usersJurisdiction’s assessment dateFiling deadline and local format rules
Pricing to sellHomeownerCurrentOwner may want a range; you report a value

When a homeowner tagged ‘Remove PMI’ calls, ask whether they have spoken with their servicer. If the servicer insists on ordering its own valuation, your report can still help them decide whether to ask, but say so clearly before they pay you.

How should appraisers price private assignments against lead cost?

Price by complexity and risk, then check that your lead spend per signed assignment is a small share of the fee. If you close one in three leads at $45, each assignment costs $135 in leads.

Illustrative lead-cost math by purpose
PurposeExample feeBidClose rateLead cost per assignmentShare of fee
Estate (retrospective)$650$5540%$13821%
Divorce$600$5035%$14324%
Tax appeal$450$4045%$8920%
Pricing to sell$450$3030%$10022%
Remove PMI$450$2520%$12528%

Fees, bids and close rates above are illustrative; use your own numbers. If a purpose consistently exceeds the share of fee you are comfortable with, lower that bid or raise your close rate with faster, clearer scoping. Testimony, rush delivery and complex properties should carry their own line items in the engagement letter.

What should you ask on the first call?

Six questions: why they need the appraisal, who will rely on it, what date the value should be as of, what the property is, when they need it, and whether anyone else (attorney, servicer, board) has format requirements.

  1. 1What is the appraisal for? (Confirm it is not for a loan application.)
  2. 2Who else will read or rely on the report?
  3. 3What date should the value be as of: today, a date of death, a separation date or an assessment date?
  4. 4What kind of property is it, and has anything changed since that date?
  5. 5When is your deadline, and is it fixed by a court, a board or the IRS?
  6. 6Does your attorney, servicer or assessor require a specific form or credential?

Say what you will not do

Homeowners often hope for a particular number. Explain early that you will report an independent opinion of value, whatever it turns out to be. It builds trust and protects you.

How do you handle PMI-removal leads honestly?

Ask about the servicer before you quote. If the servicer orders its own valuation, explain that your report is for the owner’s planning only, and let them decide whether it is worth the fee.

The Homeowners Protection Act lets borrowers request cancellation once the balance is scheduled to reach 80% of original value and ends PMI automatically at 78% for borrowers who are current (12 U.S.C. 4902). Removal based on today’s higher value is different: it follows the investor’s and servicer’s rules on seasoning, loan-to-value and payment history, and many servicers order their own appraisal or broker price opinion. Some servicers accept an owner-ordered appraisal from an appraiser on their approved list; many do not.

  1. Step 1

    Ask

    Who services the loan, how long they have had it, and whether they have asked the servicer what it requires.

  2. Step 2

    Advise

    If they have not asked, suggest they call first. It costs you a quick sale and earns you a client for life.

  3. Step 3

    Document

    If they proceed, write the servicer caveat into the engagement letter and name only the owner as intended user unless the servicer agrees otherwise.

How do you build repeat private appraisal work?

Turn homeowners into referrals to the professionals around them: family-law and estate attorneys, CPAs, tax consultants and agents. Deliver on time, explain your report clearly, and they come back.

One estate assignment often introduces you to an attorney who handles dozens a year. Keep a short, factual one-page summary of your private services for professionals and send it after each completed job, with the client’s permission. Mortgages+ also runs flat-fee Joint Venture campaigns aimed at these professionals; the appraiser lead program overview explains the offers, and our appraisal independence marketing rules cover what you can and cannot promise in that material.

Pricing-to-sell clients often need a listing agent next. Recommending one is fine; receiving anything of value for the recommendation is not. Our how listing agents buy their own leads shows how agents receive their own leads directly.

How fast should you respond to private appraisal leads?

Within minutes during business hours, and before the next morning at the latest. Tax-appeal and divorce clients are often calling several appraisers at once against a fixed deadline.

Set your daily cap to the number of new inquiries you can call within an hour while you are in the field. A text that says ‘I am on an inspection, I will call at 2:30 with a fee and timeline’ holds a lead far better than silence. Send the engagement letter by email the same day, with an e-signature link and a clear payment term.

Frequently asked questions

Can I do a retrospective appraisal for an estate?

Yes, if you are competent in the market. The effective date is the date of death, and you rely on data available as of that date, which you state in the report.

Should I quote a value range on the phone?

No. Quote a fee, report type and turnaround. A value comes only from completing the assignment.

Can my report be used later for a refinance?

Generally not. The lender must engage its own appraiser under appraiser-independence rules. Tell clients this up front.

Do tax appeal boards accept private appraisals?

Many do, but rules vary by jurisdiction. Ask the client for the board’s requirements and the deadline.

What if the homeowner wants a higher value?

Explain that your opinion is independent and you cannot accept an assignment conditioned on a value. Decline if they insist.

Clients who keep the house after a divorce usually need a buyout loan next, and a divorce buyout refinance pre-approval shows them what that takes.

More for appraisal management companies and appraisers

Curious what the homeowner sees before they become your lead? Read our appraisal guide for homeowners.

Sources

Content reviewed November 18, 2026 against these authoritative sources.

  1. 1.The Appraisal Foundation: Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP)
  2. 2.CFPB: When can I remove private mortgage insurance (PMI) from my loan?
  3. 3.IRS: Gifts and inheritances (basis of inherited property)
  4. 4.eCFR: 12 CFR 1026.42: Valuation independence
  5. 5.U.S. Code (Cornell LII): 12 U.S.C. 4902: Termination of private mortgage insurance

Photo: A magnifying glass over a model house by Sasun Bughdaryan on Unsplash (Unsplash License).

Mortgages+ marketplace

Start buying private appraisal leads today

Create an account, add money and place your first bid. You control categories, ZIP codes, caps and price.

Already a partner? Sign in to the partner portal. Prefer to talk first? See partnerships, joint ventures and investor options.