Reviewing valuation documents with a calculator

For appraisal management companies and appraisers

Private Appraisal Leads for Appraisers and AMCs

Mortgages+ sends appraisers consented leads for non-lending appraisals only: PMI removal, divorce, estate, tax appeal and pre-listing. Bid per lead from $25, by ZIP.

Appraisers cannot buy their way into mortgage work, and they should not try: federal appraiser-independence rules require the lender to choose and engage the appraiser. Private appraisal work is different. Homeowners who need a value for removing mortgage insurance, dividing property in a divorce, settling an estate, appealing a tax assessment or pricing a sale hire an appraiser directly. This page explains how Mortgages+ finds those homeowners, how the three offers work for appraisers and AMCs, and the independence, USPAP and licensing rules that shape every assignment.

Key takeaways

  • Leads are for non-lending appraisals only. Mortgage appraisals are ordered by lenders or AMCs and are never sold as leads.
  • Each lead is tagged by purpose: remove PMI, divorce or estate, property tax appeal, or pricing to sell.
  • Every lead is phone-verified with a timestamped TCPA consent record, ZIP and timeline.
  • You set a fixed bid per lead from $25, never a fee tied to a value conclusion or a closed loan.
  • Intended use, effective date and intended users drive scope, so ask about them on the first call.

When do appraisal leads happen around a mortgage?

Every lead on Mortgages+ starts at a mortgage moment: a purchase, a refinance or an equity decision. These are the windows when homeowners need you most.

  1. 1

    Two to five years into a loan with PMI

    Any time after 2 years of payments

    A current value to see if removal is worth requesting, after checking the servicer’s rules

  2. 2

    Divorce or legal separation

    Before settlement or a buyout refinance

    A defensible current or retrospective value, sometimes testimony

  3. 3

    Death of an owner

    Weeks to months after the date of death

    A retrospective date-of-death value for basis and estate filings

  4. 4

    Tax assessment notice

    Often 30 to 60 days to appeal

    A value as of the assessment date in a format the board accepts

  5. 5

    Preparing to sell

    1 to 3 months before listing

    An independent value to set a price and anticipate the buyer’s appraisal

Which appraisal leads can appraisers legally buy?

Leads for appraisals the homeowner orders directly for a non-lending purpose: PMI removal research, divorce, estate and date-of-death values, tax appeals and pre-listing pricing. Leads for mortgage appraisals are not sold.

The Truth in Lending Act’s valuation independence provisions and Regulation Z prohibit coercing or influencing an appraiser in a consumer credit transaction secured by a home, and require that appraisers be independent (15 U.S.C. 1639e; 12 CFR 1026.42). In practice, the lender or its appraisal management company selects the appraiser for a mortgage. A homeowner or lead buyer cannot steer that choice. That is why Mortgages+ does not sell lending-appraisal leads at all.

What Mortgages+ does and does not send to appraisers
Homeowner needSent as a lead?Why
Value to support a PMI removal requestYesOwner-ordered; the servicer decides what valuation it accepts
Divorce or legal separationYesClient is a spouse or attorney; may need a retrospective date
Estate, trust or date-of-death valueYesSupports basis and estate filings; often retrospective
Property tax appealYesValue as of the assessment date for the appeal board
Pricing before listingYesOwner wants an independent opinion before choosing a list price
Appraisal for a purchase or refinance loanNoLender or AMC must select and engage the appraiser

When do homeowners need a private appraisal?

Around equity events: two to five years into a loan when PMI removal becomes possible, at divorce or death, at tax reassessment, and before listing. Each has a different effective date and audience.

The mortgage moment is what links them. A homeowner checking their amortization schedule for the 80% mark realizes they may be close to 80% of original value. A divorcing couple has to decide who keeps the house and refinances. Heirs need a date-of-death value to establish basis. A family appealing a jump in taxes needs a value as of the assessment date. Our consumer explainer on home appraisals walks owners through each of these and sends the ones who want help to you.

  • PMI removal: borrowers can request cancellation at 80% of original value under the Homeowners Protection Act; removal based on current value follows investor and servicer rules.
  • Divorce: often a current value, sometimes a retrospective value as of separation; may require testimony.
  • Estate: retrospective value as of the date of death, used for stepped-up basis and estate filings.
  • Tax appeal: value as of the jurisdiction’s assessment date, with deadlines that are often only weeks after notices go out.
  • Pre-listing: current market value to set a list price and anticipate the buyer’s lender appraisal.

How do the three Mortgages+ offers work for appraisers and AMCs?

Bid on private appraisal leads from $25 by ZIP and purpose, hire Mortgages+ for flat-fee marketing campaigns, or become a founding partner and buy leads at a 30% discount. None of it touches lending assignments.

  1. Step 1

    Real-Time Leads

    Fund a prepaid wallet of at least four times your bid, choose the appraisal category, your ZIPs or states and daily caps, then bid from $25 per lead in $1 steps. The highest funded bid in the ZIP wins each request exclusively, so no other appraiser gets it from Mortgages+, and it arrives within seconds with the purpose tag.

  2. Step 2

    Joint Ventures

    A monthly marketing retainer for campaigns around your private services: divorce and estate landing pages, tax-appeal season email, content for attorneys and CPAs. Because appraisal is a RESPA settlement service when used in a mortgage, the fee is a flat marketing fee at fair market value for marketing actually performed, never tied to assignments, values or closed loans.

  3. Step 3

    Partners

    Founding partners pay a one-time fee for a stake in the platform’s growth, earn it back inside the bidding system at a 30% discount on leads, and get featured placement and co-marketing kits.

Two companion pages go deeper: pricing and scoping private appraisal assignments, and a compliance walk-through on appraiser independence when marketing to homeowners.

01 · Bid from $25 per lead

Real-Time Leads

Bid from $25 per lead on homeowners who need non-lending appraisals, tagged PMI, divorce or estate, tax appeal, or pricing to sell, by ZIP with daily caps.

Add money & place a bid

02 · We market for you

Joint Ventures

Flat-fee monthly campaigns for your private appraisal services (divorce, estate, tax appeal), priced at fair market value for marketing performed and never tied to assignments, values or loans.

Discuss a joint venture

03 · Own a piece of the platform

Partners

A one-time founding partner fee for a stake in platform growth, earned back at a 30% discount on leads, plus featured placement and co-marketing kits.

Become a partner

Any success-fee or revenue-share arrangement that requires state licensing, regulatory approval or a specific legal structure (for example, settlement-service providers covered by RESPA) must be handled independently by the partner, or the licensing, contracting and legal work needed to make it compliant will be billed in addition to the program fees.

What rules govern appraisers who buy leads?

Appraiser-independence rules for any lending work, USPAP’s ethics and competency requirements, state licensing and AMC laws, RESPA where an appraisal feeds a mortgage, fair housing, and the TCPA when you call or text.

  • USPAP: the Ethics Rule bars accepting an assignment, or compensation, contingent on a predetermined value or direction in value. A fixed per-lead price paid to Mortgages+ has no link to your conclusions (The Appraisal Foundation).
  • Advertising: USPAP also prohibits false or misleading advertising. Do not promise a value, a ‘high appraisal’ or a guaranteed PMI removal.
  • Licensing: work within your credential level and state. The Appraisal Subcommittee’s National Registry lists credentialed appraisers (ASC).
  • Lending use: if a homeowner later wants your report for a refinance, explain that the lender must engage its own appraiser.
  • TCPA: our consent covers the homeowner’s request. Call from your own compliant systems and honor opt-outs (47 U.S.C. 227). The FCC’s one-to-one consent rule was vacated in January 2025 and is not in force.
  • Fair housing and bias: valuation must never be influenced by protected characteristics. The 2024 interagency guidance on reconsiderations of value reflects how seriously regulators take this (Federal Reserve SR 24-3).

Decline mis-tagged mortgage requests

If a homeowner says the appraisal is for a loan they are applying for, tell them the lender orders it and decline the assignment. Note it in your file.

How do private appraisal assignments differ from lender work?

The client is the homeowner or their advisor, not a lender; the effective date may be in the past; the report may face an opposing party; and there is no AMC managing scheduling or payment. You own the whole relationship.

Appraisers who have spent years on AMC panels sometimes find private work jarring at first. Nobody sends you an order form with the scope pre-filled. The homeowner may not know what ‘intended use’ means. A divorcing spouse may be hostile, and an estate home may be empty, half-cleared or in disrepair. The upside is that you set the fee, you control the calendar, and satisfied clients and their attorneys send more work without an intermediary taking a cut.

Practical differences by assignment type
AssignmentKey deliverableCommon pitfallHow strong firms handle it
PMI researchCurrent value the owner can compare with servicer rulesOwner assumes your report removes PMIServicer check written into the engagement letter
DivorceNeutral report both sides can rely onOne spouse blocks accessEngage through both attorneys; schedule in writing
EstateRetrospective date-of-death valueCondition today differs from date of deathInterview the executor; state assumptions clearly
Tax appealValue as of the assessment dateMissed filing deadlineCalendar the deadline at intake; offer a rush fee
Pre-listingCurrent value and market commentaryOwner wants a list-price recommendationReport value; refer pricing strategy to the agent

AMCs can run the same playbook at scale: route each purpose tag to panel appraisers who are competent in it, standardize engagement letters by purpose, and track turnaround and client satisfaction separately from lending work. Keep private and lending pipelines visibly separate so nobody confuses a homeowner-ordered report with a lender assignment.

Credential level matters too. Assignments a licensed residential appraiser can take for private use may differ from what federal rules allow for lending, and some courts and boards expect a certified appraiser. Confirm with the client’s attorney or the board before you accept.

How should an appraiser convert a private appraisal lead?

Call within minutes, confirm the purpose, intended users and effective date, quote a fixed fee and turnaround, and send an engagement letter the same day. Clarity on scope is what wins these assignments.

  1. Step 1

    First call

    “Hi Lee, this is Pat, a certified residential appraiser. You asked about an appraisal for a property tax appeal in 60614. When is your appeal deadline?”

  2. Step 2

    Scope questions

    Intended use, intended users (owner, attorney, court, servicer, assessor), effective date, property type, access and any deadline.

  3. Step 3

    Quote and engagement

    Fixed fee, turnaround and report type in a written engagement letter. Never quote a value range on the phone.

  4. Step 4

    Follow-up

    If they hesitate, follow up on day 2 and day 5, and before their deadline. Then stop.

Referral relationships compound. Family-law and estate attorneys, CPAs and property tax consultants send repeat work. Our divorce and family-law partner overview and the property tax and HOA partner program explain how those professionals use the platform.

How should appraisers set bids and caps?

Bid by the value of the assignment and how quickly you can schedule it. Estate and divorce work often supports higher bids; tax appeals cluster in a few weeks each year, so raise caps in season.

Start with ZIPs inside your competency and drive-time radius. Set a daily cap equal to the inspections you can schedule within your quoted turnaround. Raise bids before local assessment notices go out, when appeal demand spikes, and lower them once deadlines pass. You pay only for leads you win, charged to your wallet at your bid; keep at least four times your bid funded to stay in the auction, and pause, top up or change ZIPs any time.

Review results by purpose tag every month: leads won, contact rate, engagements signed and average fee. Purposes that bring repeat professional referrals, such as estate work that introduces you to probate attorneys, deserve credit beyond the first fee. Purposes that rarely convert, often PMI research in markets where servicers order their own valuations, deserve a lower bid or a smaller cap rather than a blanket cut across your account.

Illustrative bid plan for a solo certified residential appraiser
Purpose tagBidDaily capReason
Divorce or estate$552Higher fees, retrospective work, repeat attorney referrals
Property tax appeal$35 (raise to $45 in season)3Seasonal demand and short deadlines
Pricing to sell$302Fast turnaround, often referral to agents
Remove PMI$251Check servicer acceptance first; lower close rate

Bidding, step by step

  1. Step 1

    Create your account

    Tell us your business, licenses and service area. It takes about three minutes.

  2. Step 2

    Add money

    Fund your wallet. To place a bid it needs at least 4 × the bid; you only ever spend what you load.

  3. Step 3

    Choose category and ZIPs

    Pick private appraisal leads, the ZIP codes or states you serve and a daily cap.

  4. Step 4

    Place a bid from $25

    Bid in $1 steps. The highest funded bid for the category and ZIP wins each lead; ties go to the earliest bid.

  5. Step 5

    Win leads exclusively

    Each consented, phone-verified request goes to one partner per category, by email and in your portal within seconds.

  6. Step 6

    Tune as you go

    Raise, lower or pause bids and change ZIP codes. You pay your bid only for leads you win.

A bidding example (illustrative)

Illustrative: a two-appraiser firm in suburban Ohio funds $1,200, bids $50 on divorce and estate leads and $35 on tax-appeal leads across 18 ZIPs, with a combined cap of 3 a day. Their $50 bid needs at least $200 in the wallet. If they win twenty leads in a month at a blended $42, the wallet is charged $840. Before the county’s appeal deadline they raise the tax-appeal bid to $45 for three weeks.

Compliance for appraisal partners

Appraiser independence (TILA §129E / Reg Z), USPAP and state licensing; lending appraisals are ordered by the lender, never sold as leads. Every Mortgages+ lead carries the consumer’s timestamped “Get Code” consent, the exact consent wording, IP and device. You pay for the lead itself, never for a closed transaction or a referral.

Appraisal leads: frequently asked questions

Can I buy leads for mortgage appraisals?

No. Appraiser-independence rules require the lender or its AMC to select the appraiser for a mortgage. Mortgages+ only sends leads for non-lending appraisals.

Is paying for appraisal leads a USPAP problem?

USPAP prohibits fees contingent on a value or result. A fixed price per lead, paid regardless of the assignment outcome or value, has no such contingency. Disclose any payment for procuring an assignment as USPAP requires.

Can AMCs bid as well as individual appraisers?

Yes. AMCs can bid on private appraisal leads and route them to panel appraisers, consistent with state AMC laws.

Will a servicer accept my appraisal for PMI removal?

It depends on the servicer and investor. Many order their own valuation. Tell homeowners to check with their servicer first.

Are leads exclusive?

Yes. Each request is auctioned once per category, and the highest funded bid for that ZIP wins it exclusively (ties go to the earliest bid). No other appraiser receives the same lead through Mortgages+.

Do you charge anything per assignment or value?

No. You pay a fixed bid only for leads you win, or a flat monthly marketing fee. Nothing depends on the assignment, the value or a loan.

Can I bid on a whole state instead of individual ZIP codes?

Yes. Choose a whole state when you place a bid and it covers every ZIP code in that state, including ZIPs added later; you can remove individual ZIPs you don't serve. ZIP-level and state-level bids compete on price alone, and ties go to the earliest bid.

Who handles licensing and legal work for success fees or revenue sharing?

The partner does. Any success-fee or revenue-share arrangement that requires state licensing, regulatory approval or a specific legal structure (for example, settlement-service providers covered by RESPA) must be handled independently by the partner, or the licensing, contracting and legal work needed to make it compliant will be billed in addition to the program fees. Settlement-service providers such as lenders, title and escrow companies and real estate agents pay a flat marketing fee at fair market value, never a success fee tied to closings, and Real-Time Leads are always priced per lead delivered.

Homeowners who learn their value often ask about refinancing next. Point them to an equity-aware refinance pre-approval and let their lender order the loan appraisal.

Go deeper on private appraisal leads

Where these leads come from

See the page your future customers read

Homeowners find you through Home Appraisals Explained: Lender and Private Appraisals, then request matched help with a verified phone and recorded consent.

Sources

Content reviewed November 18, 2026 against these authoritative sources.

  1. 1.U.S. Code (Cornell LII): 15 U.S.C. 1639e: Appraisal independence requirements
  2. 2.eCFR: 12 CFR 1026.42: Valuation independence
  3. 3.The Appraisal Foundation: Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP)
  4. 4.Appraisal Subcommittee: National Registries
  5. 5.Federal Reserve (SR 24-3): Interagency Guidance on Reconsiderations of Value of Residential Real Estate Valuations
  6. 6.U.S. Code (Cornell LII): 47 U.S.C. 227: Restrictions on use of telephone equipment

Photo: Reviewing valuation documents with a calculator by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash (Unsplash License).

Mortgages+ marketplace

Ready for private appraisal leads from the mortgage moment?

Create your account, add money and set your first bid in minutes. Or talk to us about a joint venture or a founding partnership.

Already a partner? Sign in to the partner portal. Prefer to talk first? See partnerships, joint ventures and investor options.