Signing closing documents

Title & escrow partners · RESPA-compliant title marketing

RESPA-Compliant Title Insurance Marketing, Tested

RESPA-compliant title marketing pays only for goods or services actually received at fair market value, never for referrals, and never tied to orders, closings or volume.

Title and escrow sits at the center of RESPA Section 8 enforcement because the business is referral-driven and the dollars are hidden inside closing costs. This page lays out what the statute and Regulation X actually say, how marketing services agreements fell out of favor, which arrangements pass and fail, and a checklist you can run on any marketing spend before you sign.

Key takeaways

  • Section 8(a) bans giving or accepting anything of value under an agreement to refer settlement-service business.
  • Section 8(c) allows payment for goods or facilities actually furnished or services actually performed, at fair market value.
  • Payments that rise with the number of orders referred are the clearest red flag.
  • Buying consented consumer leads at a flat per-lead price is the model regulators have described as the safer path.

What does RESPA Section 8 prohibit for title companies?

It prohibits giving or accepting any fee, kickback or thing of value under an agreement or understanding that settlement-service business will be referred, and it prohibits splitting charges for services not actually performed.

The statute is short (12 U.S.C. 2607). Section 8(a) covers referral payments. Section 8(b) covers unearned fees, meaning any portion of a charge received for something other than services actually performed. Section 8(c) carves out payments for goods, facilities or services actually provided, as long as they are at fair market value. Regulation X adds that a thing of value includes almost anything: money, discounts, trips, office space, payment of another person’s expenses and business opportunities (12 CFR 1024.14).

An agreement to refer does not need to be written. Regulators and courts can infer it from a pattern, such as payments that track order volume or that stop when orders stop. Penalties include fines up to $10,000 and up to one year in prison, and consumers can sue for three times the charge for the settlement service.

Are marketing services agreements still safe for title agencies?

Rarely. The CFPB’s 2015 bulletin warned that many marketing services agreements were disguised referral payments, and most of the title industry wound them down. The bulletin was later rescinded, but the statute it described still applies.

Compliance Bulletin 2015-05 explained that MSAs, where a title company or lender pays a broker or agent to market its services, carry substantial legal and regulatory risk because the payments are often tied to referrals in practice (CFPB). The CFPB rescinded the bulletin in 2020 and replaced it with RESPA Section 8 FAQs (CFPB RESPA FAQs), which restate the fair-market-value test rather than bless MSAs. State regulators and private plaintiffs still bring cases. Treat any MSA with a referral source as high risk.

In February 2023, the CFPB issued an advisory opinion on digital mortgage comparison-shopping platforms, saying a platform that steers consumers toward the provider that pays it, or pays more, can violate Section 8 (Federal Register). The CFPB withdrew a large batch of guidance documents in 2025; regardless of an opinion’s status, the underlying statute and Regulation X are unchanged, and the practical lesson holds: pay for the lead, not the outcome, and do not buy steering.

Which title marketing arrangements pass or fail the RESPA test?

Arrangements pass when you pay a non-referrer, or pay a referrer only for real goods or services at market rates unrelated to volume. They fail when the payment, its size or its continuation depends on orders.

Common title marketing arrangements and how they usually read under Section 8
ArrangementUsually reads asWhy
Buying consumer leads at a flat per-lead price from a platformLower riskPayment is for the lead delivered, not a referral or a closing
Paying a platform a share of the title premium on closed filesHigh riskPayment tracks business generated
Renting desk space at a brokerage at market rent you actually useCan passMust be documented, used and priced at fair market value
Renting desk space nobody sits inFailsPayment for nothing except the referral relationship
Paying an agent’s Zillow or portal billFailsPaying a referral source’s expenses is a thing of value
Hosting a CE class open to all agentsCan passEducational and not conditioned on referrals
Joint mailer where each party pays its shareCan passEach pays a proportionate, fair-market cost
Flat monthly marketing retainer to a non-referrer for campaigns runCan passFixed fee for services actually performed, at fair market value

This is why Mortgages+ prices title leads per lead from $25 and prices its Joint Venture campaigns as a flat fee for marketing actually performed. The structure is described on our title and escrow marketplace overview, and the pricing math is in this breakdown of per-lead costs for title agencies.

What about Section 9 and affiliated title companies?

Section 9 stops sellers from requiring a buyer to use a particular title insurer. Affiliated title agencies are legal if the consumer gets a written disclosure, is not required to use the affiliate, and the only return is an ownership share.

A seller who conditions a sale on the buyer using a certain title company is liable to the buyer for three times the title charges (12 U.S.C. 2608). Builders and brokerages with affiliated title agencies must give an affiliated business arrangement disclosure, cannot require use of the affiliate (with narrow exceptions), and may receive only a return on ownership, not payments that vary with referrals (12 CFR 1024.15). For an unaffiliated agency, Section 9 is an opportunity: a buyer who chooses you is protected in doing so.

What should be on a title marketing compliance checklist?

Before any spend, confirm who gets paid, what they deliver, how the price was set, whether it varies with orders, and whether you can prove the service was performed.

  1. 1Is the payee in a position to refer settlement business to us? If yes, apply extra scrutiny.
  2. 2What exactly do we receive, and can we prove it was delivered (leads, ad placements, reports)?
  3. 3How was the price set? Keep a market comparison on file.
  4. 4Does the amount, renewal or continuation depend on orders, policies or closings? If yes, stop.
  5. 5Does the consumer know they can choose their title company?
  6. 6Is there any ownership link that requires an affiliated business disclosure?
  7. 7Do state title rules cap gifts, promotional items or inducements, and does this spend fit?
  8. 8Is TCPA consent documented for every consumer we will call or text?
  9. 9Has counsel reviewed the agreement, and is the file retained for at least five years?

Not legal advice

This checklist is a practical screen, not a legal opinion. RESPA is enforced by the CFPB, state attorneys general and private plaintiffs, and state title laws vary. Have counsel review any agreement with a referral source.

Frequently asked questions

Is buying title leads a RESPA violation?

Paying a flat price for a consented consumer lead, not tied to whether the file closes, is the structure regulators have treated as lower risk. Paying a share of revenue on closed files or paying a referral source for leads is not.

Can a title company pay a lead platform a percentage of each closing?

That structure ties payment to business generated and creates serious Section 8 risk. Per-lead pricing avoids it.

Are marketing services agreements illegal?

Not per se, but they must pay fair market value for marketing actually performed and cannot be tied to referrals. In practice many title companies stopped using them because the line is hard to prove.

Can a seller choose the buyer’s title company?

A seller may not require the buyer to use a particular title company as a condition of sale. In some markets the seller customarily pays for the owner’s policy, but the buyer’s choice is still protected by Section 9.

What penalties apply to RESPA Section 8 violations?

Fines up to $10,000 and up to one year in prison per violation, plus private suits for three times the settlement charge, along with CFPB and state enforcement.

Want to see the consent screens your leads pass through? Review the consented pre-approval flow behind title leads.

More for title agencies, underwriters and escrow companies

Curious what the homeowner sees before they become your lead? Read our title & escrow guide for homeowners.

Sources

Content reviewed November 18, 2026 against these authoritative sources.

  1. 1.U.S. Code (Cornell LII): 12 U.S.C. 2607, RESPA Section 8: prohibition against kickbacks and unearned fees
  2. 2.U.S. Code (Cornell LII): 12 U.S.C. 2608, RESPA Section 9: title companies; liability of seller
  3. 3.eCFR: 12 CFR 1024.14, Prohibition against kickbacks and unearned fees (Regulation X)
  4. 4.eCFR: 12 CFR 1024.15, Affiliated business arrangements (Regulation X)
  5. 5.CFPB: Compliance Bulletin 2015-05: RESPA compliance and marketing services agreements
  6. 6.CFPB: Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act FAQs (including Section 8)
  7. 7.CFPB (Federal Register): Advisory opinion: RESPA Section 8 and digital mortgage comparison-shopping platforms (Feb 2023)

Photo: Signing closing documents by Scott Graham on Unsplash (Unsplash License).

Mortgages+ marketplace

Start buying title and escrow leads today

Create an account, add money and place your first bid. You control categories, ZIP codes, caps and price.

Already a partner? Sign in to the partner portal. Prefer to talk first? See partnerships, joint ventures and investor options.