Reviewing an insurance quote at a laptop

Homeowners insurance partners · Lead cost

How Much Do Homeowners Insurance Leads Cost?

Homeowners insurance leads on Mortgages+ start at a $25 bid. What matters more is cost per bound policy, which depends on contact rate, quote rate and close rate.

Price per lead is the number everyone quotes and the number that matters least. A $25 lead that never answers is expensive; a $60 lead from a buyer with a closing date can be a bargain. This page shows how to do the math, compares common buying models, and gives you a worksheet you can run on your own numbers.

Key takeaways

  • On Mortgages+ you set your own bid per lead, starting at $25, and pay only for leads delivered from a prepaid balance.
  • Cost per bound policy = bid ÷ (contact rate × quote rate × bind rate). Track all three.
  • Purchase leads with a closing date tend to justify higher bids than general re-shop leads in the same ZIP.
  • Measure payback against first-year commission plus realistic retention and bundles, not the single policy.

What do homeowners insurance leads cost on Mortgages+?

You choose your bid, with a $25 minimum per lead. Each delivered lead debits your prepaid balance at your bid, and when several agencies target the same ZIP, the highest funded bid wins the lead exclusively.

There is no setup fee to bid and no charge for requests you do not receive. You fund a balance, pick the homeowners insurance category, set ZIP codes and daily caps, and decide what a lead is worth to you. The full mechanics are on the homeowners insurance partner overview.

What moves your effective price (illustrative)
LeverEffect on costWhen to use it
Higher bidRaises price per lead, wins more ZIP auctionsZIPs where your carriers are competitive and you can call fast
Narrower ZIP listFewer leads, usually better fitCarrier appetite is limited by geography or wind/hail exposure
Daily capPrevents spend outrunning staffSmall teams or after-hours coverage gaps
Request typePurchase vs owned vs rental vs condoBid more where your book converts best

How do you calculate cost per bound policy?

Divide your price per lead by the share of leads that become bound policies. If 70% answer, 60% of those get a quote and 30% of quotes bind, about 12.6% of leads bind, so a $35 lead costs roughly $278 per policy.

  1. Step 1

    Contact rate

    Leads you actually speak with ÷ leads delivered. Speed to first call drives this more than anything.

  2. Step 2

    Quote rate

    Leads you quote ÷ leads contacted. Carrier appetite and roof age decide much of it.

  3. Step 3

    Bind rate

    Policies bound ÷ quotes delivered. Price, service and the closing deadline drive it.

  4. Step 4

    Cost per policy

    Bid ÷ (contact × quote × bind). Compare it with the value of a new household, not one premium.

Illustrative scenarios (your rates will differ)
ScenarioBidContactQuoteBindCost per policy
Slow follow-up, general re-shop$2545%55%20%≈ $505
Fast follow-up, general re-shop$2570%60%25%≈ $238
Fast follow-up, buyer under contract$3570%60%30%≈ $278
Fast, under contract, with auto bundle$4575%65%35%≈ $264

Notice the second row. The cheapest lead got cheaper per policy only because the agency called faster. Before you raise or cut a bid, fix response time.

What is a homeowners insurance customer worth to an agency?

More than one year of commission. Value a new household on first-year commission plus expected renewals and the auto or umbrella policies it usually brings, then set a maximum cost per policy below that.

Use your own commission schedule and retention data. A simple illustrative model: a $2,400 annual home premium at a 12% new-business commission pays $288 in year one. If renewals pay 10% and the policy stays four more years, that is about $960 more. Add an auto bundle and the household value can double. Against that, a $278 cost per policy pays back in the first year.

  • Set a ceiling: the most you will pay per bound policy and still hit your margin target.
  • Work backward: ceiling × your expected bind ratio = your maximum bid.
  • Recheck monthly: carrier rate changes and appetite shifts move bind rates fast.
  • Count bundles separately so you know which ZIPs bring whole households.

How do Mortgages+ leads compare with other ways to buy insurance leads?

Per-lead bidding gives you price control and real-time delivery. Aggregator call transfers, shared web leads and aged lists each trade price for intent, freshness or consent quality in different ways.

Common models for buying personal-lines leads
ModelWhat you pay forWatch out for
Mortgages+ Real-Time LeadsEach consented, ZIP-targeted request at your bid (from $25)Exclusive per category; still act fast
Live call transfersA connected call, usually priced per callConsent chain behind the transfer; call duration rules
Generic shared web leadsA form fill sold to several buyersUnclear consent wording, many competing callers
Aged leadsOlder records at a steep discountStale intent; consent may not cover your agency
Joint Venture marketingA flat monthly fee for campaigns run for your agencyMeasure on reporting, not on per-policy fees (RESPA)

Whatever you buy, keep the consent record. If a complaint arrives under the TCPA, the burden is on the caller to show consent (47 CFR 64.1200). For channel strategy beyond price, compare this with our look at where agencies find homeowners insurance prospects.

How should a new agency test its first budget?

Start with a balance that buys 30 to 50 leads in your best ZIPs, bid modestly above the $25 minimum, call every lead within minutes, and judge results after at least 30 days.

  1. 1Pick 15 to 30 ZIPs where your carriers write new business today.
  2. 2Fund enough for 30 to 50 leads at your bid. At $32, $1,200 covers 37 leads.
  3. 3Set a daily cap your team can call within five minutes during business hours.
  4. 4Log contact, quote and bind for every lead in your CRM or agency management system.
  5. 5After 30 days, raise bids in ZIPs that bind and pause the ones that do not.

No pay-per-policy deals on required insurance

Do not convert lead spend into a fee per policy bound or per loan closed. When a lender requires the coverage, a per-transaction payment can look like a referral fee under RESPA Section 8.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a monthly minimum?

No. You fund a prepaid balance and pay only for leads delivered at your bid. You can pause or top up any time.

Why would I bid above $25?

The highest funded bid in a ZIP wins each request exclusively, so a higher bid wins more leads. Agencies often bid more in ZIPs and request types that bind well for them.

Are refunds offered for bad leads?

Ask our team about current marketplace terms before you fund. Price your bid assuming every delivered lead counts against your balance.

What is a good cost per bound homeowners policy?

It depends on your commission, retention and bundle rate. Work out the lifetime value of a household first, then set a ceiling below it.

Do purchase leads cost more than re-shop leads?

You set the bid, so you can bid more for “A home I’m buying” requests if your data shows they bind more often.

Many leads arrive before the buyer has a loan, so it helps to suggest a pre-approval to buyers shopping for coverage before they start touring homes.

More for homeowners insurance agencies and carriers

Curious what the homeowner sees before they become your lead? Read our homeowners insurance guide for homeowners.

Sources

Content reviewed November 18, 2026 against these authoritative sources.

  1. 1.eCFR: 47 CFR 64.1200: Delivery restrictions (FCC TCPA rules)
  2. 2.Cornell LII: 47 U.S.C. 227: Restrictions on use of telephone equipment (TCPA)
  3. 3.Cornell LII: 12 U.S.C. 2607: Prohibition against kickbacks and unearned fees (RESPA Section 8)
  4. 4.Insurance Information Institute: Facts + Statistics: Homeowners and renters insurance
  5. 5.Harvard Business Review: The Short Life of Online Sales Leads (2011)

Photo: Reviewing an insurance quote at a laptop by Scott Graham on Unsplash (Unsplash License).

Mortgages+ marketplace

Start buying homeowners insurance leads today

Create an account, add money and place your first bid. You control categories, ZIP codes, caps and price.

Already a partner? Sign in to the partner portal. Prefer to talk first? See partnerships, joint ventures and investor options.